January 6, 2008

The Obsession

Posted by Eric at 8:06 am | Category: Academia, Links, Literature, Science

There are two classes of scientists that always amaze me in a “how the hell do they do that?” way.

The first are scientists that do fifty different things in ten different fields, excelling in all of them and contributing fundamental new discoveries in each of them. George Whitesides is a classic example of this. He’s been studying physical organic chemistry, microfluidics, surface chemistry, biochemistry, materials chemistry, nanotechnology, and even dabbling in a little origins-of-life speculation. The guy knows his stuff, that’s for sure.

The other side of the coin are those scientists that pick one topic and stick with it for their entire career, often for decades; the only thing that changes is their technique. Paul Schimmel is one guy like that; he has been studying tRNAs and tRNA synthetases for over 30 years, from before the advent of DNA sequencing through the modern genomic era. It’s incredible; I can’t imagine doing this. First, how do you find so many questions to ask about one topic? Second, don’t you ever get tired of this? And yet, even now, he’s still churning out Nature and Science papers on his obsession — there’s really no other way to put it.

4 Responses to “The Obsession”

  1. Ben Says:
    January 6th, 2008 at 3:18 pm

    Two ways to think about this:
    1. Whitesides = GE, Schimmel = Toyota?
    2. I don’t know about you, but the deeper I get into a subject, the more interesting questions there are to ask. What I’m amazed more about is how Whitesides can do what he does; Schimmel makes sense to me…

  2. Eric Says:
    January 6th, 2008 at 4:48 pm

    But to keep producing Nature and Science papers on it after 30 years? It’s amazing; you’d think he’d have long ago descended into obscurity.

  3. kayesdee Says:
    January 14th, 2008 at 2:39 pm

    Schimmel has had the luck of working in proximity of an exploding science based around new DNA/Protein technologies. Imagine he was studying rocks or the sex life of whales… or whatever ;)

    But then I feel more like Whitesides… expanding horizontally rather than zooming in vertically.

    It is probably just two different types of people?

  4. Eric Says:
    January 14th, 2008 at 6:55 pm

    I suppose that mainly they’re two types of people, and also the kind of topic they’re interested in. I know Whitesides likes interdisciplinary research a lot, so he dabbles in lots of things on the frontier of physics, chemistry, and biology. I think he also fancies himself a philosopher of sorts, so he likes to read about a lot of different things, which creates all these different interests. Perhaps Schimmel is more just extraordinarily excited about this one thing, and every time something new comes out, he wants to try it on this system. And as Ben said, new questions always come up if you’re curious and study one particular system in depth.

Leave a Reply